Israeli Government Influence Prosecution of Palestine Action Court Cases

Aug 20, 2023

Click here to view correspondence between Israeli embassy and Attorney Generalโ€™s Office

As reported in the Guardian today, correspondence disclosed by the Attorney Generalโ€™s Office (AGO) shows the Israeli Embassy in London attempting to exert diplomatic influence on the prosecution of Palestine Action activists.

The disclosures, made under the Freedom of Information Act, show correspondence between the Director General of the Attorney Generalโ€™s Office, Doug Wilson, with representatives of the Israeli Embassy in London, over the period May 2022 to February 2023. While most of these representatives have their names redacted, we know that one is Oren Marmorstein, Deputy Ambassador of Israel to the UK [1].

In an email dated 9th May 2022, at which time Suella Braverman held the post of Attorney General, Wilson updates the Embassy on matters previously discussed in a meeting. He notes having raised matters on the embassyโ€™s behalf to their Home Office colleagues, relating to Law Officerโ€™s ability to intervene in prosecution decisions and casework. The parties also discussed the โ€˜operational independence of the CPS [Crown Prosecution Service]โ€™, and the AGOโ€™s ability to bring about prosecutions.

The same email notes a discussion between the parties relating to domestic protest law, including the governmentโ€™s intended โ€˜strengthen[ing] of policy powers to tackle non-violent protestsโ€™ of a โ€˜disruptiveโ€™ nature. Furthermore, Wilson adds that, in the meeting, โ€˜we also mentioned the Attorney Generalโ€™s power to refer questions of law to the Court of Appealโ€™, and their having done so recently in relation to the Colston Four. This came four months before the judgement in this appeal ruling [2], a ruling which then largely stripped Palestine Action activists of their rights to the Article 10 and 11 protections of the European Convention on Human Rights. These defences, their Freedoms of Expression and Assembly, were denied due to the activistsโ€™ targeting of private property โ€“ property belonging to Elbit Systems, Israelโ€™s largest private weapons company.

Over the past year, therefore, there is clear and compelling evidence that the Israeli apartheid state have been attempting to exert pressure over the Director General of the Law Officerโ€™s Department, Doug Wilson, as regards matters of British domestic law, policing, and prosecutions. This email, of the 9th May, came during months of intensive and widespread direct action against the sites and offices of Elbit Systems, which saw two Elbit premises in London and Oldham close permanently [3].

More recently, in an email dated 1st February 2023, four months into Victoria Prenticeโ€™s tenure as AG, the Israeli embassy contacted Wilson. The correspondence discusses the making of a joint declaration between the respective countriesโ€™ Ministries of Justice โ€“ the body which oversees the judiciary, courts, prisons and probation โ€“ to seek โ€˜closer bilateral cooperationโ€™ over โ€˜legislation and legal reform, civil and criminal law and legal eductionโ€™. The final point to note is the partiesโ€™ discussion of โ€˜special mission immunityโ€™, with an apparent reticence on the part of the Israeli embassy to host a visit of Israeli officials given the possibility of arrests for war crimes committed. 

With the former head of the Foreign Office, Dominic Raab, having met with Israeli officials to discuss Palestine Action in 2021 [4], we now have confirmation also of AGO, Home Office, and Ministry of Justice collusion with the occupation regime of Israel. Palestine Action have stated:

โ€œThis is confirmation of what has been suspected for a long time, that the Israeli state is attempting to exert top-level diplomatic influence to lock up those who stand against its war machine. This undue influence further damages the credibility of charges brought against activists, who have faced criminal trials, sentencing, and litigious harrassment for their action taken against the manufacturers of Israelโ€™s murderous weaponry.

This goes some way to explaining the ludicrous charges brought against activists: conspiracy to blackmail, aggrevated criminal damage, or a seven week trial for โ€˜going equippedโ€™ โ€“ these bogus charges have been brought about because the heads of the British Attorney Generalโ€™s Office, Ministry of Justice, and police have been working in close collaboration with an apartheid state. In the coming months weโ€™ve over 100 activists due to stand trial, and the possible prison sentences faced represent an injustice of global proporions given that the Israeli war machine has clearly taken hold of British courts.

If this has surfaced now after just one Freedom of Information request, we urge all supporters to undertake research themselves, and to find what else is out thereโ€

NOTES TO EDITORS 

If you would like any further information on Palestine action, please contact info@palestineaction.org 

Palestine Action is a direct-action network of groups and individuals formed with the mandate of taking action against the sites of Elbit Systems and other companies complicit in Israeli apartheid, calling for all such sites to be shut down. 

[1] https://embassies.gov.il/london/AboutTheEmbassy/Pages/Deputy-Ambassador.aspx

[2] https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/AG-Ref-Colston-Four-judgment-280922.pdf

[3] https://mondoweiss.net/2022/06/israeli-weapons-maker-shuts-london-hq-following-sustained-protest/

[4] https://electronicintifada.net/blogs/asa-winstanley/uk-turns-counterterror-law-repress-palestine-action